Brian Reich

Remember Hyperlinks?

Quick Summary The hyperlink gave us a fair, free, democratic web. Pay-to-play search, social algorithms, and LLMs have taken the lead out of its pencil.


Remember hyperlinks? Let me refresh your memory. In the before times, before being seen in search results was largely a pay-to-play exercise, before social media algorithms hijacked our gray matter, and before AI gobbled up humanity’s collective knowledge and became our “enshittified oracle,” before all of that… we had hyperlinks.

This is a short history of the hyperlink and how it lost its potency. It’s also a case for why those of us who build for the web should put humans first by embracing the hyperlink as a tool for communicating trust and navigating the human side of the web.

Hyperlinks were how we connected sites together. A page author could link one page to another by adding a special tag, called an anchor or <a> tag, around words to make the text clickable. Visitors discovered new things by clicking hyperlinks to navigate to something else.

<a href="https://example.com/sporks">
  all about sporks
</a>

The web was literally a web of interconnected pages, spread across thousands of sites all over the world. The hyperlink was a simple concept that gave rise to a complex and interconnected information network.

The primary design principle underlying the Web’s usefulness and growth is universality. When you make a link, you can link to anything.

— Tim Berners-Lee, Long Live the Web (2010)

Hyperlinks were simple, but finding what you wanted was hard unless you already knew where to look. Navigating the pre-search engine web was like a Choose-Your-Own-Adventure where, if you clicked the wrong thing, there was a nonzero chance you were getting emotionally scarred.

Directories, like the original Yahoo!, gave the web a table of contents. Shortly after, search engines truly made the public web navigable by slurping up all the public information and creating an index. They gave us a way to find pages based on search terms.

Search made public content discoverable. But links were still at the center of everything. Search engines didn’t give you the content itself: they gave you a link to the content, a title, and a summary of what you might find on the other side of that hyperlink.

Search engines used programs called crawlers to read the pages they already knew about and use hyperlinks to discover new pages. Without hyperlinks, search engines wouldn’t know where to look to find new information.

Links were also an authority signal: if one site linked to another using the keyword spork for example, there was a good chance the target site had something to say about sporks. If many sites linked to the same site using the spork keyword, it was a good sign that it was an authoritative source on the topic of sporks and it should display higher in search results.

It wasn’t perfect (linking can be gamed). But it was fair, free, and democratic.

Anyone willing to learn some HTML could make a website. Anyone who could do that could add a hyperlink. It cost nothing, and it was mutually beneficial. By linking to someone else’s content you’re providing your visitors with an option to explore their own interests further, and you’re giving the destination page a vote of confidence.

It wasn’t perfect. But it was fair, free, and democratic.

What I just described is the web its inventors gave us. We turned it into, well… something else.

While working on my business’s SEO and social media strategy, I started thinking about the web we left behind.

Hyperlinks are still here. But three “improvements” to our online experience have taken all the lead out of the hyperlink’s pencil, so to speak.

Search went pay-to-play. Paid search visibility reduced the value of authority by making money authoritative. To be fair: organic search results still exist… below the ads where many people never see them.

Social media became the front door. It replaced search engines as the “homepage of the Internet,” and replaced the authority of page relationships with the authority of the friends, people, and organizations you follow. Initially, social media showed us content by the people we followed. Eventually, algorithms took over, deciding what to show us based on who’s paid to be seen and what’s most likely to capture and keep our attention. We see what the algorithm lets us see.

Large social-networking sites are walling off information posted by their users from the rest of the Web.

— Tim Berners-Lee, Long Live the Web (2010)

LLMs made the link beside the point. Large Language Models (LLMs) have gobbled up the entire public Internet, as well as most of humanity’s legally protected, copyrighted knowledge. It’s not crazy to think that LLMs have devalued the act of creating your own website in the first place, let alone linking to other people’s sites. Hyperlinks don’t matter much when your experience of the web is whatever your LLM decides it should be.

What we gave up

Our current experience of the web relieves us of our agency. Social media algorithms shape our beliefs and opinions by curating our perception of the world and the people within it. LLMs relieve us of the burden of thinking for ourselves. There are better and worse ways to use AI, and unfortunately, many people don’t approach it as a tool, but as an oracle that grants access to hidden knowledge, a genie that grants wishes, or a god that is infallible. LLMs are none of those things, and pretending they are is incredibly dangerous.

Of course, letting social media and AI shape your experience of the web is a choice. At least for now. So before you make it, I want to remind you of the things we’ve given up as the web has evolved from a web of many loose connections into a small collection of walled gardens that curate your experience to their own benefit.

Then

An open web of links

Now

A few walled gardens

The same number of sites, wired two ways. On the open web any page could link to any other. Inside a walled garden everything points at the platform, and the sites left outside are hard to find.
  1. Small sites being findable on merit. It’s increasingly difficult for small sites to get traction. Search engine optimization is highly competitive, paid search crowds out organic results, and social media algorithms reward the people with the money to promote their content and the resources to post a constant stream of it.
  2. Community on open terms. Webrings, blogrolls, forums, and personal home pages let people build communities around shared interests and vouch for each other in the open. Everyone wanted a homepage once. They were weird and fun. But today, communities have migrated to walled gardens where someone else controls the flow of information. When you build on top of someone else’s platform, your content, your URLs, and your ability to reach your audience can all go away for any reason that platform chooses. One of the best ways to guard against that is to own your identity: your own website, on your own domain.
  3. Choosing what you see. RSS let us subscribe to the sites we care about and build our own news feed. It still exists, and readers like Feedly still work, but it’s largely been crowded out by algorithm-curated feeds. Clicking from link to link used to take you places you didn’t know to look for. A feed shows you more of what you already engaged with, and an LLM answers the question you asked and stops there.
  4. Credit, and a reason to publish. A search engine handed you a link to the content, and the author got the visit and the vote of confidence. An LLM hands you the content itself, without the credit, which shrinks the audience that made publishing worthwhile. The decline of Stack Overflow is the key example. It was already losing ground, and then LLMs finished it off: they slurped up its content and became a better interface for getting the answers, and because it no longer gets as much human traffic, there’s less incentive for people to keep posting questions or answers.
  5. Judging for yourself. When you land on a page, you can see who wrote it, what their angle is, and what they left out, and weigh that against other sources. A summary flattens everything into one confident voice, and you’re left to take it or leave it.

Here’s what that Stack Overflow decline looks like.

Questions asked on Stack Overflow each month

August 2008 to October 2026

Source: the public Stack Exchange API, retrieved November 18, 2026. It counts questions still on the site, so deleted questions aren't included.
Show the numbers by year
Questions asked on Stack Overflow per year
YearQuestions
2008 (Aug to Dec) 57,122
2009 340,177
2010 688,356
2011 1,180,004
2012 1,611,811
2013 2,016,144
2014 2,113,424
2015 2,175,603
2016 2,182,745
2017 2,099,319
2018 1,875,594
2019 1,755,581
2020 1,854,911
2021 1,534,103
2022 1,334,593
2023 787,553
2024 398,322
2025 108,938
2026 (Jan to Oct) 19,625

I didn’t set out to complain about the state of things. I wanted to celebrate the web that we left behind, and to wonder out loud if there’s value in the noble hyperlink that we lost without making a conscious decision to give it up.

Maybe that’s nostalgia. I grew up with the early Internet, and we humans have a tendency to think that the way things used to be was better. So let me be clear: the web, and our lives, are in many ways better with search, and some aspects of social media and large language models. I just think they’ve been corrupted, in a way that the organic, free, fair, democratic nature of the link-driven web never was.

Links were intentional: they empowered web authors and readers alike. Links allowed content authors to choose what they did or didn’t trust as a source of information on the topic they were writing about. Links gave the reader the power to choose what they did or didn’t see next on their journey. Links were a valuable tool on a web built for humans. And as builders of the web, we get to decide who we build it for. My answer: humans first.

How to put the lead back in the pencil

Here’s the painful truth.

We didn’t lose the hyperlink in one dramatic moment. We incrementally traded away its value as a navigational tool and a trust signal for convenience. Links offer a way to navigate the web that’s empowering, but requires you to exercise critical thinking. Social media and AI just give you what they think you want, no thinking required. We chose the don’t make me think experience.

I still love the web as a thing built for humans. It’s still out there, in personal sites, small businesses, hobbyist blogs, and people who just like explaining things. If you’re one of the people still writing and building for humans, I have a favor to ask: link to each other again.

We chose the don’t make me think experience.

You might be wondering: Why bother, if the feeds and the chatbots don’t care? Because we’re still building for humans, and links are useful to humans. A link tells your reader where to go next. It tells them who you trust, and lets them judge that relationship and the information you’re linking to for themselves. And it tells the author on the other end that someone read their work and thought it was worth sharing.

And the search engines never stopped counting. Crawlers still follow links to find new pages, and links are still a signal that search engines use to rank search results. And that still matters if you care about organic search engine optimization.

So link the tool you swear by. Link the post that changed your mind. Link the small site that answered your question, not just the one that ranked first. Keep a blogroll, if you’re feeling brave. It costs nothing, takes about four seconds, and it’s a vote of confidence that doesn’t need a platform’s permission.

Remember hyperlinks? Go make some.


Wondering how your organization gets linked to? We don’t sell link building, and we’ll tell you honestly whether you need it and point you to people who do it well. What we do build is a fast, human-first website worth linking to. Get in touch and we’ll talk it through.

Get in touch

Want a website worth linking to?

Tell us about your site and we'll tell you honestly what would help it get found, and whether we're the right people to do it.

  1. Tell us what's going on. Tell us in your own words what problem you're having, what goal you'd like to meet, or what dream you want to make reality.
  2. Hear back within a business day. I read every message myself.
  3. Talk it through. A free 30-minute call, if it helps.

Rather talk now? Call (570) 939-7322.